Sign in to follow this  
Pickleberry

Clash of Engineers - Issue with Voting RNG Selection

Recommended Posts

Error report
Describe problem and what you saw

I'm seeing the same author show up frequently in Clash of Engineers Voting stage.

Many times this happens back-to-back;

AdmirableNegativeKillerwhale-size_restri

What you expected to see I expect to be able to see all users' builds fairly.
Conditions in which error reproduce Cycle through builds and keep track.  It's very easy to see the same author show up multiple times.
Problem details

image.png.013563d77d33526e7db32cf833d723

I logged 501 build views while refreshing in the Clash of Engineers - FHT event.

The first 100 times I refreshed, I saw the same authors 15 times.
By the 200th, I saw the same authors 67 times.
By the 300th, I saw the same authors 125 times.
By the 400th, I saw the same authors 211 times.
By the 501th, I saw the same authors 297 times.

This means that out of 501 views, I only saw 204 unique builds ( 59.40% Duplicate Author Rate )

Many users I saw a radical amount of times:
- I saw 4 users' builds 7 times each
- I saw 7 users' builds 6 times each
- I saw 7 users' builds 5 times each
- I saw 20 users' builds 4 times each
- I saw 44 users' builds 3 times each
- I saw 62 users' builds 2 times each
- I saw only 60 users' builds once.

** This means that the top 17 people accounted for 100 of my 500 views alone. 17 out of 204 people!

Frequency of reproduction always
Time of bug Since Clash of Engineers Voting Stage

 

FULL LOG BELOW:

BUILD AUTHOR View #
FHT spatial OpT***o X #001
FHT VooDoo Jun***Tah #002
Beginer FHT Sil***edi #003
FHT NASASECURITY Joh*** NA #004
FHT flydisabled Mee***aaW #005
FHT Ramjet Too***amz #006
FHT sic shuttle II *** II #007
FHT Bomber B70***i3D #008
FHT LOL SWI***DOG #009
Fht air flies Ter***T20 #010
FHT Dragster sma***lll #011
FHT red red***464 #012
FHT Bob***ban #013
LolFHT Tha***and #014
FHT FIGHTER G4R***4JA #015
Fht simplton SN0***DER #016
Navigator FHT pit***ll7 #017
FHT CLASSIC WWI raz***o13 #018
FHT Dog Fight Il *** lI #019
Fht air flies Ter***T20 #020
FHT Dueler Sab***307 #021
FHT Cricket rse***est #022
FHT Grounded RUG***IWI #023
Spit FHT The***uid #024
FHT A10 Warthog Ger***294 #025
FHT jet Gia***oob #026
FHT Apache Cre***t03 #027
Plane FHT Sim***out #028
FHT rampant jbow Deu***tor #029
FHTClaw Sr ***law #030
FHT or Flight Che***313 #031
Auto FHT gre***nd1 #032
FighterFHT Fat***s93 #033
GroundAttack FHT Hur***r1s #034
WastelandJetFHTr AFo***ing #035
Short CircuitFHT Gna***d69 #036
FHT Falcon The***Mon #037
FHT jet Gia***oob #038
FHT BI PLANE PUN***004 #039
Fht air flies Ter***T20 #040
FHT FIGHTER 0013 vic***r08 #041
DogFHT Biplane Slo***ien #042
FHT Target034 Cap***rFr #043
Nomadfighter FHT GLD***Elf #044
FHT shuttle Om3***ppo #045
FHT A10 Reb***420 #046
FHT He 162 A1 Wea***948 #047
FHT NUMBER 1 DrP***pin #048
FHT Scorched XpL***VEs #049
FHT PEREGRINE W1G***R4L #050
FHT Dueler Sab***307 #051
GroundAttack FHT Hur***r1s #052
FHT fighter srt***eed #053
FHT PEREGRINE W1G***R4L #054
FHT Jet End***657 #055
FHT Tr1***4n1 #056
FHT desert storm JD ***e00 #057
FHT Fighter Bra***hus #058
FHT SpaceShuttle TWI***L V #059
FHT Harrier R34***MON #060
FHT MBP MBP***L92 #061
Beginer FHT Sil***edi #062
FHT Freedom Wra***h78 #063
FHT fighter kry***p4c #064
WORKING VTOL FHT cre***uts #065
FHT Dueler Sab***307 #066
RaisePhoenixFHT Gra***ale #067
Beginer FHT Sil***edi #068
FHT Orca1 Chu***r3t #069
FHT jet DTP***sis #070
FHT Gunship Cat***ime #071
FHT tunder Pet***890 #072
FHT BF109Fighter DAN*** Jd #073
FHT jetcar TBo***lta #074
FHT Apollo14 Cro***ede #075
FHT Stealth Wil***tis #076
FHT Trash Jet XxF***eXx #077
WORKING VTOL FHT cre***uts #078
FHT H0Z0R Glider H0Z***Z0R #079
FHT Delta Law***cko #080
FHT Strike Fight The***lek #081
FHT spatial OpT***o X #082
FHT IWANT SMR sam***ser #083
FHT or Flight Che***313 #084
Crimson BaronFHT The***eer #085
FHT Def DA ***IES #086
Messyschmitt FHT ElJ***yle #087
GroundAttack FHT Hur***r1s #088
H4RR13R FHT R3D***1NG #089
FHT shuttlejump Bud***One #090
FHT Chopper dav***hat #091
FHT Delta Law***cko #092
dr4g0nfLy FHT GAM***JR2 #093
FHT rampant jbow Deu***tor #094
FHT Old Reliable BRO***H17 #095
FHT Su 55 JAK***per #096
FHT Dakkajet Mr ***uss #097
FHT skyfall eri***age #098
FHT Chopper dav***hat #099
FHTWardog Ize***e25 #100
FHT AC130 XO Pro***ign #101
Wasteland FHT roc***tof #102
FHT Hunter BRT***SEY #103
Dx FHT Sopwith Bli***ier #104
FHT MiG 17 ACE***388 #105
FHT plane Pos***to1 #106
FHT HUNTERSTELAR Dri***r38 #107
FHT He 162 A1 Wea***948 #108
FHT spatial OpT***o X #109
FHT INTERCEPTER MUI***LLS #110
FHT NUMBER 1 DrP***pin #111
FHT fighter kry***p4c #112
FHT flydisabled Mee***aaW #113
FHT Thunderbird AC ***2ee #114
FHT Thunderbird AC ***2ee #115
FHT jet Gia***oob #116
FHT MiG17 ACE***388 #117
FHT Viper Jel***pse #118
FHT Red Baron iii***iii #119
FHT Fighter DrZ***bos #120
FHT AC130 XO Pro***ign #121
FHT Spitfire Spr***ady #122
FHT Ane Tau***sh3 #123
FHT Dakkajet Mr ***uss #124
FHT Red baron Mis***r83 #125
FHT Leviathan cns***all #126
FHT JOULE69LS Dev*** 69 #127
FHT BRAVO 6 OSS***YYO #128
FHT Baron IFa***iah #129
FHT skyfall eri***age #130
FHT Deddy Jet Mr *** 74 #131
FHT Hunter BRT***SEY #132
Crimson BaronFHT The***eer #133
BLACKHAWK FHT LIL***EEE #134
FHT Hunter BRT***SEY #135
FHT SpaceShuttle TWI***L V #136
FHT Red Baron iii***iii #137
FHT Number 1 DrP***pin #138
Fht air flies Ter***T20 #139
Fht simplton SN0***DER #140
Plane FHT Bul***ife #141
FHT fighter srt***eed #142
Fht Unt***r99 #143
FHT AV8B HARRIER mem***eat #144
1949FHT tha***agg #145
FHT plane Pos***to1 #146
FHT RED BARON RSD***OOM #147
FHT Bob***ban #148
FHT Road Ace ALA***999 #149
FHT flight Duck Gav***234 #150
WastelandJetFHTr AFo***ing #151
FHT Gunship Cat***ime #152
FHT Dueler Sab***307 #153
FHT FIGHTER JET Twi***Nz4 #154
FHT Red Baron iii***iii #155
FHTWildprojectB1 Zeu***der #156
FHT Bomber B70***i3D #157
FHT shuttlejump Bud***One #158
FHT AV8B HARRIER mem***eat #159
FHT Magicschool PUN***BMF #160
FHT Phantom 2 Gor***022 #161
FHT INTERCEPTER MUI***LLS #162
FHT Lone Wolf DG ***olf #163
FHT Deddy Jet Mr *** 74 #164
Beginer FHT Sil***edi #165
FHT Blue Angel Rav***ura #166
FHT Dueler Sab***307 #167
FHT tunder Pet***890 #168
Short CircuitFHT Gna***d69 #169
FHTjt KUN***K45 #170
Spit FHT The***uid #171
GroundAttack FHT Hur***r1s #172
FHT Modified Sat***115 #173
FHT Deddy Jet Mr *** 74 #174
Short CircuitFHT Gna***d69 #175
FHT I_207 Mrs***jar #176
dr4g0nfLy FHT GAM***JR2 #177
GroundAttack FHT Hur***r1s #178
FHT Silver ROM***978 #179
FHT Su 55 JAK***per #180
FighterFHT Fat***s93 #181
FHT Red Baron iii***iii #182
FHT TheBaron xlx***0kx #183
NomadfighterFHT GLD***Elf #184
F14 FHT Kor***hor #185
FHT FIGHTER 0013 vic***r08 #186
FHT The Fun Guns Pou***cks #187
Navigator FHT pit***ll7 #188
FHT 45 Dam*** V2 #189
FHT B17 Fortress xXJ***ero #190
Beginer FHT Sil***edi #191
Spit FHT The***uid #192
F15 FHT Rob***ght #193
Plane FHT Sim***out #194
FHT Red Baron iii***iii #195
FHT RhumStation SLY***TIF #196
RaisePhoenixFHT Gra***ale #197
FHT Boss Duck For***ion #198
FHT SPOOKY KIK***AVE #199
FHT  Jet Fighter The***360 #200
FHT fight plane xXH***rXx #201
FHT Air Bus Lim***oLo #202
FHT Flying Tire sni***101 #203
FHT old faithful kil***995 #204
FHT Scorched XpL***VEs #205
FHT BRAVO 6 OSS***YYO #206
dr4g0nfLy FHT GAM***JR2 #207
FHT jet DTP***sis #208
H4RR13R FHT R3D***1NG #209
FHT Leviathan cns***all #210
FHT NUMBER 1 DrP***pin #211
FHT RED BARON RSD***OOM #212
FHT Dueler Sab***307 #213
FHT Landjet Cyb*** 01 #214
FHT dis***oom #215
FHTClaw Sr ***law #216
F14 FHT Kor***hor #217
Night Duck FHT SER***210 #218
FHT Apache Cre***t03 #219
FHT Deddy Jet Mr *** 74 #220
FHT NNNYYYOOOOMM Spi***962 #221
FHT Stellaris The***nt9 #222
FHT Air Bus Lim***oLo #223
FHT Garbage Devs M 4***420 #224
FHT Scrap Plane Flu***956 #225
Fighter FHT Tra***413 #226
FHT A10 Reb***420 #227
FHT CLASSIC WWI raz***o13 #228
FHT sic shuttle II *** II #229
FHT Garbage Devs M 4***420 #230
FHT MiG 17 ACE***388 #231
B 29 FHT SNA***OKA #232
FHT Grounded RUG***IWI #233
the FHT machine Lig***n94 #234
FHT Bi Wing Mou***200 #235
FHT Thunderbird AC ***2ee #236
FHT Falcon The***Mon #237
FHT BF109Fighter DAN*** Jd #238
FHT Bi Wing Mou***200 #239
FHT Trash Jet XxF***eXx #240
FHT SPOOKY KIK***AVE #241
F14 FHT Kor***hor #242
FHT Dark Hawk 64 STE*** 05 #243
FHT plane Tep***nJr #244
FHT Deddy Jet Mr *** 74 #245
FHT Ripper Sho***tor #246
FHT AC130 XO Pro***ign #247
FHT Quake bfe***t76 #248
FHT BI PLANE PUN***004 #249
Spit FHT The***uid #250
Dx FHT Sopwith Bli***ier #251
FHT BI PLANE PUN***004 #252
FHT 474 War***ACR #253
FHT goblin Mr ***ian #254
FHT Eurofighter Twi***ndz #255
FHT Flying eater jac***990 #256
FHT mig 19 Dik***Doo #257
FHT BRAVO 6 OSS***YYO #258
FHT Star ship CDM***tom #259
Beginer FHT Sil***edi #260
FHT MiG 17 ACE***388 #261
FHT old plane Sou***ow2 #262
FHT Bomber Rob***tes #263
FHT goblin Mr ***ian #264
FHT Wyvern Pur***tic #265
FHT Delta Law***cko #266
FHT Gardius xTH***cer #267
FHT Streamliner Env***hot #268
FHT LOL SWI***DOG #269
FHT RED BARON RSD***OOM #270
GroundAttack FHT Hur***r1s #271
FHT plane Pos***to1 #272
Fht Unt***r99 #273
FHT Star ship CDM***tom #274
FHT The Fun Guns Pou***cks #275
FedAnaconda FHT AZU***UN0 #276
FHT_NFZ4 Gha***m37 #277
FHT Hunter BRT***SEY #278
FHT xXS***x2k #279
FHT AC130 XO Pro***ign #280
FHT stealth Iff***ffy #281
FHT Hunter BRT***SEY #282
GroundAttack FHT Hur***r1s #283
FHT dis***oom #284
FHT Dogfight Box***ons #285
FHT rampant jbow Deu***tor #286
FHT Harrier x S***z x #287
FHT fight plane xXH***rXx #288
FHT Landjet Cyb*** 01 #289
FHT Fighter Jet Neg***nce #290
FHT Freedom Wra***h78 #291
Mtnduke89 Fht Mou***e89 #292
Beginer FHT Sil***edi #293
FHT Dueler Sab***307 #294
FHT Glider Orb***iFx #295
FHT AV8B HARRIER mem***eat #296
FHTP82twin Sit***ll1 #297
FHT flight der***ate #298
FHT BartiniVVA14 YOU***IDE #299
FHT MiG 17 ACE***388 #300
FHTWardog Ize***e25 #301
FedAnaconda FHT AZU***UN0 #302
FHT Aces Ace***ame #303
FHT Old Reliable BRO***H17 #304
FHT BRAVO 6 OSS***YYO #305
FHT Ace G H***man #306
FHT or Flight Che***313 #307
FHT SpaceShuttle TWI***L V #308
BLACKHAWK FHT LIL***EEE #309
FHT fighter Mar***rim #310
FHT plane Tep***nJr #311
FHT MiG 17 ACE***388 #312
FHT Target034 Cap***rFr #313
FighterFHT Fat***s93 #314
FHT Stellaris The***nt9 #315
A10 FHT Psy***910 #316
RaisePhoenixFHT Gra***ale #317
dr4g0nfLy FHT GAM***JR2 #318
FHT Fighter Bra***hus #319
FHT Derp der***O G #320
FHT Fighter DrZ***bos #321
FHT Fighter CL ***Si3 #322
FHT flydisabled Mee***aaW #323
FHT BRAVO 6 OSS***YYO #324
FHT Quake bfe***t76 #325
FHT Fighter DrZ***bos #326
FHT xXS***x2k #327
FHT Garbage Devs M 4***420 #328
FHTWILDprojectB1 Zeu***der #329
FHT Ace G H***man #330
FHT JOULE69LS Dev*** 69 #331
FHT flight Duck Gav***234 #332
FHT Future Tech ATO***AVE #333
FHTWardog Ize***e25 #334
FHT Stealth Wil***tis #335
FHT Gunship Cat***ime #336
FHT Code bravo Bla***XXX #337
Nomadfighter FHT GLD***Elf #338
FHT BRAVO 6 OSS***YYO #339
FHT Phantom 2 Gor***022 #340
FHT Dark Hawk 64 STE*** 05 #341
Spit FHT The***uid #342
RaisePhoenixFHT Gra***ale #343
FHT stealth Wil***tis #344
FHT NUMBER 1 DrP***pin #345
FHT Scorched XpL***VEs #346
FHT Fighter Bra***hus #347
FHT Cardinal Pot***ury #348
FHT Bi Wing Mou***200 #349
FHT P_51 Mustang DAN***1BR #350
FHT Blue Angel Rav***ura #351
FHT Ane Tau***sh3 #352
FHT Eurofighter Twi***ndz #353
FHT BI PLANE PUN***004 #354
Nomadfighter FHT GLD***Elf #355
FHT flight der***ate #356
dr4g0nfLy FHT GAM***JR2 #357
Plane FHT Sim***out #358
FHT dis***oom #359
FHT FIGHTER 0013 vic***r08 #360
FHT fighter srt***eed #361
FHT Future Tech ATO***AVE #362
FHT Dec***322 #363
FHT Red baron Mis***r83 #364
FHT fighter kry***p4c #365
FHT RED BARON RSD***OOM #366
FHT BF109Fighter DAN*** Jd #367
FHT FIGHTER G4R***4JA #368
FHT 45 Dam*** V2 #369
WastelandJetFHTr AFo***ing #370
FHT Blue Angel xX *** Xx #371
FHT xXS***x2k #372
FHT Code bravo Bla***XXX #373
FHT Magicschool PUN***BMF #374
FHT Blackbird DEA***XX7 #375
FHT sic shuttle II *** II #376
FHT Trash Jet XxF***eXx #377
FHT Boss Duck For***ion #378
Wasteland FHT roc***tof #379
FHT Bin Eat***n 7 #380
FHT old plane Sou***ow2 #381
FHT A10 Warthog Ger***294 #382
RaisePhoenixFHT Gra***ale #383
Messyschmitt FHT ElJ***yle #384
FHT_NFZ4 Gha***m37 #385
FHT Tr1***4n1 #386
FHT goblin Mr ***ian #387
FHT fighter Mar***rim #388
FHT Ramjet Too***amz #389
FHT Viper Jel***pse #390
FHT Dakkajet Mr ***uss #391
FHT AC130 XO Pro***ign #392
FHT flight der***ate #393
FHT Garbage Devs M 4***420 #394
the FHT machine Lig***n94 #395
FHT 45 Dam*** V2 #396
FHT A10 Warthog Ger***294 #397
FHT Apache Cre***t03 #398
FHT Ripper Sho***tor #399
FHT IWANT SMR sam***ser #400
FHT Quake bfe***t76 #401
FHT Hunter BRT***SEY #402
FHT Bob***ban #403
FHT Grounded RUG***IWI #404
FHT Dogfight Box***ons #405
FHT old plane Sou***ow2 #406
FHT Apollo14 Cro***ede #407
FHT F17 LOR***YER #408
FHT rampant jbow Deu***tor #409
FHT Stealth Iff***ffy #410
FHT Gunship Cat***ime #411
FHT Red baron Mis***r83 #412
H4RR13R FHT R3D***1NG #413
FHT Blue Angel Rav***ura #414
FHT Hornet Alp***017 #415
FHT shuttle Om3***ppo #416
Short CircuitFHT Gna***d69 #417
sky blue FHT Alm***o67 #418
FHT Fighter DrZ***bos #419
FHT NUMBER 1 DrP***pin #420
FHT Grounded RUG***IWI #421
Navigator FHT pit***ll7 #422
FHT Vague comp Bon***Inc #423
FHT Streamliner Env***hot #424
FHT Delta Law***cko #425
FHT Aces Ace***ame #426
Fht fuseeee tho***110 #427
FHT Dog Fight Il *** lI #428
FHT dis***oom #429
FHT Dakkajet Mr ***uss #430
FHTWILDprojectB1 Zeu***der #431
FHT BI PLANE PUN***004 #432
FHT AC130 XO Pro***ign #433
FHT Garbage Devs M 4***420 #434
BLACKHAWK FHT LIL***EEE #435
FHT Lone Wolf DG ***olf #436
FHT Ace G H***man #437
FHT 45 Dam*** V2 #438
FHT Hornet Alp***017 #439
FHT Fighter Jet Neg***nce #440
FHTClaw Sr ***law #441
FHT Trash Jet XxF***eXx #442
FHTWILDprojectB1 Zeu***der #443
FHT Falcon The***Mon #444
FHT fighter kry***p4c #445
FHT Reaper cav***y17 #446
FHTP82twin Sit***ll1 #447
FHT Bob***ban #448
FHT Boss Duck For***ion #449
FHT Airdeath V3x***4rt #450
FHT Stealth Mr ***gel #451
FHT Dark Hawk 64 STE*** 05 #452
FHT fight plane xXH***rXx #453
FHT Fighter CL ***Si3 #454
FHT Silver ROM***978 #455
FHT BLUE ANGEL xX *** Xx #456
FHT NASASECURITY Joh*** NA #457
RaisePhoenixFHT Gra***ale #458
FHT Falcon The***Mon #459
FHT Lone Wolf DG ***olf #460
Drive to win FHT Pic***ith #461
FHT Hornet Alp***017 #462
FHT HAWK Xxx***xxX #463
FHT Phantom 2 Gor***022 #464
FHT Red Baron iii***iii #465
FHT Spitfire Spr***ady #466
FHT Vague comp Bon***Inc #467
FHT Eurofighter Twi***ndz #468
FHT Jet End***657 #469
FHT Leviathan cns***all #470
Navigator FHT pit***ll7 #471
FHT shuttle Om3***ppo #472
FHT SPOOKY KIK***AVE #473
FHT Scrap Plane Flu***956 #474
FHT Fighter CL ***Si3 #475
FHT Spitfire Spr***ady #476
FHT Deddy Jet Mr *** 74 #477
sky blue FHT Alm***o67 #478
FHT Ripper Sho***tor #479
FHT Stellaris The***nt9 #480
FHT FIGHT PLANE win*** JR #481
FHT H0Z0R Glider H0Z***Z0R #482
FHT going down FRE***OVA #483
FHTWardog Ize***e25 #484
FHT INTERCEPTER o0O***O0o #485
FHT going down FRE***OVA #486
FHT Fighter DrZ***bos #487
Night Duck FHT SER***210 #488
FHT NovaScream Cor***ite #489
Drive to win FHT Pic***ith #490
FHT A10 Reb***420 #491
FHT RED BARON RSD***OOM #492
FHT AC130 XO Pro***ign #493
FHT rampant jbow Deu***tor #494
FHT Ace G H***man #495
FHT Fighter CL ***Si3 #496
FHT fight plane xXH***rXx #497
FHT CLASSIC WWI rax***rax #498
fHT fenris WYK***OUL #499
FHT Glider Orb***iFx #500
FHT SpaceShuttle TWI***L V #501

 

Edited by Pickleberry
  • Thanks 3
  • Upvote 3

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The real sad part about this is in 501 views mine wasn't even on his list. How is that fair? :017:+

:facepalm: come on devs :crazy: improve this terrible system :008:

  • Upvote 2

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

BOOOOOO! HISSSSSSS!!!!! horrendous voting system. Such a fail. 

  • Upvote 2

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
On 10/21/2019 at 3:58 PM, A_V_G_P said:

The real sad part about this is in 501 views mine wasn't even on his list. How is that fair? :017:+

:facepalm: come on devs :crazy: improve this terrible system :008:

I have the same problem with you with the SHP contest ...

 

But Admin don't care about this ? The unfair system ?

They should take a part in the voting system. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
2 hours ago, JarJarBZH said:

I have the same problem with you with the SHP contest ...

 

But Admin don't care about this ? The unfair system ?

They should take a part in the voting system. 

I didnt even bother this time. Didnt send an entry in and didnt vote.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Sign in to follow this  

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.